The Miami Dolphins, a franchise often in the spotlight, have weathered numerous storms – from concerns surrounding Tua Tagovailoa’s concussion history to off-field incidents involving key players. No scandal has left a deeper mark than the “Bullygate”, which engulfed Miami Dolphins in 2013.
Jonathan Martin was the centre of controversy. Martin claimed severe bullying and harassment, which led to significant repercussions including the release of players and the change in coaches. Now, more than a decade after the incident, an astonishing revelation has surfaced. It shakes the very foundations of what was originally said.
Martin, a former NFL star who was recently interviewed by ESPN about his life after football dropped an explosive bombshell. “I didn’t believe for one second that I was bullied,” Jonathan Martin told ESPN. Then he added, “I’ve tried to correct this story for 10 years” – indicating that he has been wanting to make amends.

This admission reignited debate around the “Bullygate”, scandal. It has a particular impact on former offensive lineman Richie Incognito who was labeled one of the main instigators by the NFL Tedd-Wells Report, which is 144 pages long. Incognito was cut from the Dolphins after the NFL commissioned a report to investigate bullying allegations. He also lost the 2014 season and an estimated $10,000,000 in earnings.
Incognito finally responded when the attention was renewed. He told Omar Kelly, of the Miami Herald: “It has taken him 10 years before he tells the truth!” Richie Incognito wrote to me in a private exchange. He posted a series on X (formerly Twitter), expressing how he was feeling.
I was blamed by his mother because he couldn’t make it in the NFL. The legacy media has pushed the narrative far and wide. It’s a shame it was all just a lie. The liars lied in order to keep his money. He quit… the team had every right to claw back that money. He was bullied by his mom. @espn… https://t.co/ifFFJPG1H7
— Richie Incognito (@68INCOGNITO) February 16, 2025
Incognito’s remarks indicate that he believes Martin’s exit was more due to a performance issue than to systematic bullying. His statement was, “He could not make it in the NFL and quit. And his mother blamed me.” The legacy media has pushed the narrative far and wide. It’s a shame it was all just a lie. The lied in order to keep his money. He quit… the team had every right to claw back that money. He was bullied by his mom. espn Adam Schefter, so that MiamiDolphins “Don’t try to get his signing bonus!”
Incognito also shared pictures of Martin, Incognito, and their teammates in an effort to dispel the narrative.
We bullied Mike Pouncey by wearing a quilt on the buggy ride we took to Indianapolis, the evening before the game.
09/24/2013 pic.twitter.com/1XTdJ7PGoW
— Richie Incognito (@68INCOGNITO) February 16, 2025
Former Dolphins have also expressed their opinions on the resurgence of “Bullygate”. Nolan Carroll was a cornerback for the Dolphins at the time and shared his thoughts, emphasizing the wide-ranging impact of this situation.
We were a mixed bag that season, so I’m not going to say if one player ruined a whole season.
Kevin O’Neil, John Jerry, Richie, Mike P, Coach Philbin all suffered from the bad publicity and career he brought about.
Yall don’t understand everyday it was never about opponents but how bad of a locker we… https://t.co/VyAr48r6ua
— Nolan Carroll (@CarrollCity) February 17, 2025
Carroll’s comments suggest that “Bullygate”, while not perfect, was not a bullying issue. Not gonna say that one person messed up the season, because it was a roller coaster year. But the negative attention and careers he messed up, Kevin O’Neil, John Jerry, Richie, Mike P, Coach Philbin… He just ran like a coward! Acknowledging this does not help. Never will I respect him. Nolan Carroll said.
Jonathan Martin’s latest admission brings up important questions about what really happened in the “Bullygate.” scandal, and how it affected the Miami Dolphins’ organization as well as the careers and lives of those who took part. Is it true bullying, or was this a misinterpretation based on the typical locker room dynamics of NFL? What ever the cause, it changed NFL’s view of what is acceptable.
In the NFL the repercussions of “Bullygate’ continue to be felt, raising the question as to whether the accusations are justified or the result of a locker room culture gone wrong. Martin’s revelations will certainly have a long-lasting effect, whether “Bullygate”, a scandal that accurately depicted events or misinterpreted the locker room culture of the Miami Dolphins was.
NFL:
Dolphins Star Tyreek Hill Takes Shot at Mac McClung All-Star Dunk Contest Win
Dolphins Officially Release Three Veteran Players in Early Roster Purge